Library Media Connection - May 1, 2009
"The author's smooth writing complements the artwork…An excellent choice for use in units on the history of child labor or coal mining. Recommended."
The Horn Book Guide - April 1, 2009
"Carter's story, based on an actual incident, earnestly depicts the challenges of being a miner; Debon's paintings effectively illustrate the cold, dark mines and Savino's fears."
Southwestern Ohio Young Adult Materials Review Group - March 17, 2009
"The illustrations and the simple text make the story easy enough for young readers to understand Savino's emotions when he enters the mind and the dangers that he faces."
Bulletin of the Center for Children's Books - February 3, 2009
"This is a pony story with a difference, and the heroic-animal tale has considerable appeal...an absorbing tale."
School Library Journal - January 1, 2009
"Striking oil paintings in shadowy tones - sepia, brown, gray - are punctuated by the bold lines of the cart tracks and shaft supports that lead Savino into the depths and readers deeper into the story."
Tucson Unified School District - January 1, 2009
Midwest Book Review - January 1, 2009
"A striking picturebook, highly recommended for public library children's collections."
Canadian Teacher Magazine - January 1, 2009
"A fine addition to the body of excellent Canadian picture books that are superlative stories for children, beautiful works of art, and invaluable recordings of the history and culture of our country...Out of the Deeps deserves a place of honour on the bookshelves of Canadian picture book collectors and, of course, in school libraries and classrooms across the country."
CM Magazine - December 5, 2008
"Carter's storytelling is flawless and builds a superb sense of suspense and foreboding disquiet... [an] excellent and multifaceted story that presents informative and engaging insights into the dangers, drama, lifestyles, triumphs and history of mid-twentieth century Eastern Canadian coal mining children, adults, and their workhorses."
Resource Links - December 1, 2008
"The evocative writing captures the dramatic tension... [a] compelling book."